Sol Sender on Herbert Bayer

Sol Sender on designer Herbert Bayer and complicity:

“Contemporary writing about graphic design is often characterized by an inability to engage fully with the complex history from which modern design practice emerges. Too often this writing tends towards the history of form-making, or provides a shallow romanization of design heroes. When such tendencies result in a failure to address the spectacle and crimes of fascism in 1930s Germany, we are left with a critical void which demands engagement.

Deconstruction escapes the politics of modernism in its intense and sometimes obsessive analysis of the structures of language and meaning. For all the creative experimentation and intellectual exploration that deconstruction has inspired (particularly at Cranbrook in the 1980s), it has also accompanied a troubling blindness to the tragically straightforward content that history often delivers. Here, that dynamic is made evident. Ellen Lupton’s and J. Abbott Miller’s interest in the formal qualities of Herbert Bayer’s piece, Deutschland Ausstellung, and only its formal qualities (at least in this instance) — serves as an uncomfortable reminder of Bayer’s own response to being confronted with the booklet later in his career:

“When asked … about his contribution to this project for the Nazis, Bayer’s only comment was, ‘this is an interesting booklet insofar as it was done exclusively with photography and photomontage, and was printed in a duotone technique.'”

Bayer’s comment seems to reflect an inability or unwillingness to take responsibility for his actions, express public remorse or attempt to explain the conditions which precipitated his propaganda work for the Nazis. Christopher Burke, in his book on Paul Renner, describes how “Bayer later painted out all those elements in his work that made explicit Nazi references.” Perhaps Bayer was horrified by his own complicity, or perhaps he felt that it was better for his career and historical legacy to conceal and erase that work, given what the world, by then, knew about the Nazis and the Holocaust. Regardless of his motives, for us to ignore his complicity and silence forecloses on the potential for an ongoing relationship between graphic design and politics.

If we were to presume a historical evolution of modern design, beginning in 1917 and ending with the present, there would be certain defining moments. One of those moments needs to be 1936 Germany. It was a moment that should be remembered for the existence of a relationship between a designer, Herbert Bayer, and a client, National Socialism. What has survived of that moment? What can we learn from it now? For today’s designers, the question of Bayer’s complicity may provoke a concern with how our design work could inadvertently result in the success of a group, idea or product which may ultimately prove dangerous, wrong or evil. In the case of Bayer, to simply question his public consciousness (how much did he know?) avoids the larger question of responsibility for ignorant or unconscious acts of political consequence. How much do we know about our clients? How much do we care to know? How much does, or should, that knowledge affect the fundamental quality and success of our work?”

— Design and Complicity: Herbert Bayer’s Silent Legacy