Kalman/Miller/Jacobs on appropriation

“Designers abuse history when they use it as a shortcut, a way of giving instant legitimacy to their work and making it commercially successful. In the ‘80s and even today, in the ‘90s, historical reference and down and outright copying have been cheap and dependable substitutes for a lack of ideas. Well-executed historicism in design is nearly always seductive. The work looks good and it’s hard not to like it. This isn’t surprising: Nostalgia is a sure bet; familiarity is infinitely comforting…

Bad historicism reduces history to style. The history of design becomes a marketplace where we shop for style – the proverbial marketplace of ideas. We pull a style off the rack, we try it on. If it fits, we take it.

Now, the point of this article is not to argue against appropriation of ideas. And it’s certainly not to argue against influence. Designers can borrow ideas from other media, contemporary ideas or historical ideas, and transform them into good design (‘transform’ is the key word here). Cross-pollination is an important and legitimate aspect of how culture works.

What we’re arguing against is design that cashes in on history. We object to contemporary designers who take ideas that might have been radical 70 years ago but have since become legitimate – more than that, endearing and very, very safe – and reuse those ideas without even reinterpreting them. We’re not opposed to historical reference: Just as there is good history and bad history, there is good historical reference and bad historical reference. Reference means just that: You refer to something. It gives you an idea. You create something new.

There’s an important difference between making an allusion and doing a knock-off. Good historicism is not a lounge act. It’s an investigation of the strategies, procedures, methods, routes, theories, tactics, schemes, and modes through which people have worked creatively. If we have any monuments in the history of design, they should be the basis for critical evaluation.

We need to learn from and interrogate our past, not endlessly repeat its recipes. What we can learn from Constructivism is not type place at 45-degree angles and the reduction of colors to red, white, and black, but freedom with word order and the lack of strict hierarchies in the typographical message. We need to look not at the stylistic tics of Modernism but at its varied strategies. We should focus not on its stylistic iterations but on its ideas.

How can we change bad history into good history? How can we change bad historical reference into good historical reference? We need fewer coffee table books and more ambitious design writing. We need as much time spent on the editorial conception of books as is spent on sexy layouts and glossy photography. We need to ask the right questions. After all, good history is a matter of asking good questions.”

— Tibor Kalman, J. Abbott Miller, Karrie Jacobs (Good History/Bad History)